Hunting for rare armaments in Red Dead Redemption 2 gives virtual gunslingers an excellent excuse to explore the farthest corners of Rockstar's sprawling Western map. Among the most legendary items available is the Otis Miller Revolver, a beautifully engraved gold weapon hidden inside a secret chest. Finding this specific sidearm requires patience, as the game forces players to track down scattered map fragments before uncovering the final burial site.
Locating the First Torn Map Fragment
Your search begins by tracking down the first piece of the puzzle, which is held by a hostile hermit living in the far northeastern section of the map. You must travel to a remote cabin located north of Annesburg in the scenic area known as Manito Glade. Upon arriving, the resident will immediately attack you with a rare shotgun, requiring you to eliminate him to explore his property safely. Once the danger has passed, head inside the small house and search the wooden drawer next to the bed to secure the first torn map.
Tracking Down the Second Hermit
To acquire the matching half of the secret guide, you need to ride to the western edge of West Elizabeth. A reclusive hermit woman lives in a secluded wooden shanty hidden away in the mountains near Little Creek River. As you approach her territory, she will release a pack of aggressive dogs to defend her homestead from intruders. You must neutralize the threats and search the small nightstand inside her cabin to obtain the final piece of the document.
Deciphering the Cholla Springs Treasure Site
With both fragments safely assembled in your inventory, the completed document points out a specific hidden cave located far to the southwest. The destination is nestled inside a rocky outcrop in the Cholla Springs region of New Austin, just north of the San Luis River. Players should look for a small, easily missed cave opening hidden along the rugged cliffside. Navigating inside this quiet cavern will reveal a small wooden box containing the legendary prize alongside a handful of vintage photographs.
Claiming the Golden Weapon Reward
Opening the hidden chest officially awards you the beautiful Otis Miller Revolver, a custom Schofield model adorned with ivory grips. This striking gold weapon delivers excellent accuracy and fire rate, making it a valuable addition to any endgame arsenal. It represents a fantastic reward for players aiming to achieve one hundred percent completion across their gameplay journey. Collecting this historic gun allows you to wield the signature sidearm of one of the lore's most famous fictional gunslingers.